6th Man of St. John's Basketball

St. John's Red Storm => In The Jungle... => Topic started by: Marco Baldi on June 02, 2015, 06:20:56 PM

Title: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: Marco Baldi on June 02, 2015, 06:20:56 PM
I want Rawle here.
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: TONYD3 on June 02, 2015, 06:28:06 PM
One of my students plays for the Rens. He said mustapha heron is really good. But Rawle is like Lebron. He said bully's everyone.I responded that he is bullying HS kids. Hewas very adamnent that he is that good. My student is only 14. But I believe him.
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: Foad on June 02, 2015, 06:28:38 PM
I want Rawle here.

Is Margot Robbie 2016? Because I want her.
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: valgoth on June 02, 2015, 06:31:04 PM
yakwe, we will have a spot open with CO graduating for an athlete of that caliber. he is starting to look like he might be better than diallo also,
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: sju89tr on June 02, 2015, 06:34:20 PM
Heron and Yawke
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: Amaseinyourface2 on June 02, 2015, 06:40:38 PM
Heron's an easy choice for me.
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: paultzman on June 02, 2015, 06:43:08 PM
Heron's an easy choice for me.

Yup
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: Marco Baldi on June 02, 2015, 06:51:35 PM
I want Rawle here.

Is Margot Robbie 2016? Because I want her.
Never heard of him. Does he have hops?
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: lihoop on June 02, 2015, 07:37:52 PM
Mustapha & Maverick
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: Chilleb on June 02, 2015, 08:17:19 PM
Bruce Bowen/ mustapha ... Have probably seen Rawle the most out of everybody here. I'm really not a fan. I don't think his game will translate the way most people think. Of course I could be wrong and if I am I will own it, but I'll pass on the Rawle bandwagon
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: Foad on June 02, 2015, 08:56:33 PM
I want Rawle here.

Is Margot Robbie 2016? Because I want her.
Never heard of him. Does he have hops?

Mad hips.
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: Celtics11 on June 02, 2015, 10:45:07 PM
Heron's an easy choice for me.

Yup
Count me all in on Heron.
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: MCNPA on June 02, 2015, 10:50:40 PM
Mustapha Heron.  Kid is a complete player.  Big, strong, good athlete, good shooter.   Mismatch trouble for everybody at his position.  Kid is a stud and easy future pro.  An animal competitor too, that could play 1-3 spots.  Kid is the goods!
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: mullin85berry86 on June 03, 2015, 01:26:46 AM
What about that Diallo kid? Heard he could be 16 in his thread.
He's visiting tomorrow/ or later today. Read that he's nasty.
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: Tha Kid on June 03, 2015, 04:06:58 AM
Heron.
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: pmg911 on June 03, 2015, 07:39:02 AM
I want Rawle here.

Interesting - I want nothing to do with the kid...

I will take Heron and I am very interested in Kostas Antetokounmpo
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: Marco Baldi on June 03, 2015, 08:15:48 AM
I want Rawle here.

Interesting - I want nothing to do with the kid...

I will take Heron and I am very interested in Kostas Antetokounmpo

Any reason? Baggage etc?
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: capmaker on June 03, 2015, 09:11:02 AM
I want Heron / Yakwe
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: pmg911 on June 03, 2015, 09:50:38 AM
I want Rawle here.

Interesting - I want nothing to do with the kid...

I will take Heron and I am very interested in Kostas Antetokounmpo

Any reason? Baggage etc?

No specific reason..    seems like kid is very talented..    just something about him and the entire process with him that has rubbed me the wrong way...    seems like the kid wants the recruiting spotlight directed at him alone and then he certainly does have some baggage...   

Lastly, I have never been a fan of CTK in general...
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: boo3 on June 03, 2015, 10:34:03 AM
Yawke the Heron
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: desco80 on June 03, 2015, 11:28:38 AM
Alkins
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: stjohnnie75 on June 03, 2015, 12:48:58 PM
Ahmed
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: wpc77 on June 03, 2015, 01:35:53 PM
Heron.  Recruiting floodgates will open if he commits.
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: Marco Baldi on June 03, 2015, 03:07:36 PM
Heron.  Recruiting floodgates will open if he commits.

I think Heron is already on board
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: desco80 on June 03, 2015, 03:16:15 PM
Heron.  Recruiting floodgates will open if he commits.

I think Heron is already on board

Wow.

Go get Alkins then.   That would be a tough back-court.   
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: boo3 on June 03, 2015, 04:38:41 PM
As we've learned, nothing is done until they are on campus. 

Kid is going to get calls from everywhere.
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: newsman13 on June 03, 2015, 04:52:12 PM
Josh Jackson from Napa, California.  Lavin would be all over this number one, five star recruit.
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: Marco Baldi on June 03, 2015, 06:12:48 PM
I think we land Heron, Alkins, Yakwe and Ahmed
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: hnk on June 03, 2015, 06:55:00 PM
Would that be a top five class?
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: stjohnnie75 on June 04, 2015, 11:21:27 AM
I think we land Heron, Alkins, Yakwe and Ahmed

Hope you are right
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: MCNPA on June 04, 2015, 04:17:25 PM
Would that be a top five class?

Easily I'd think. 
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: PIB on June 04, 2015, 05:11:07 PM
I think we land Heron, Alkins, Yakwe and Ahmed


I'll send you a pie of pizza if that comes to fruition, lol.
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: Johnny23 on June 04, 2015, 08:17:13 PM
Josh Jackson from Napa, California.  Lavin would be all over this number one, five star recruit.

He's from Detroit. He moved out to Cali and plays for some prep team.
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: WillieG on June 05, 2015, 12:38:13 AM
Heron.  Recruiting floodgates will open if he commits.

I think Heron is already on board
I'm confused.
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: Wods317 on June 05, 2015, 08:15:23 AM
Heron.  Recruiting floodgates will open if he commits.

I think Heron is already on board
I'm confused.
Obviously Baldi feels like Herron has already made up his mind and gave the staff some kind of verbal. I won't be surprised if he commits to us but I would be surprised if he's done so already.
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: paultzman on June 05, 2015, 09:32:05 AM
Heron.  Recruiting floodgates will open if he commits.

I think Heron is already on board
I'm confused.
Obviously Baldi feels like Herron has already made up his mind and gave the staff some kind of verbal. I won't be surprised if he commits to us but I would be surprised if he's done so already.
Agree
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: sju89tr on June 05, 2015, 10:11:55 AM
Heron.  Recruiting floodgates will open if he commits.

I think Heron is already on board
I'm confused.
Obviously Baldi feels like Herron has already made up his mind and gave the staff some kind of verbal. I won't be surprised if he commits to us but I would be surprised if he's done so already.
Agree

He's going to explore his options but I think we are in a good position to land him. I just like that this staff is not putting all their eggs in one basket.
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: Marillac on June 07, 2015, 01:19:02 AM
All things considered, Heron is my top choice.  It'd be great to get him early to make a statement.  Ahmed might be next but it's difficult to adjust the impact of a kid that can play a max of two years and won't make as big of a statement in the recruiting world as nearly all the other guys we are considering.

Also love Adebayo, Alkins, Rowan, Brown, Yakwe, and Ponds.  Probably in that order.  Ponds might be the most intriguing to me.

Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: JohnnyJungle on June 07, 2015, 01:48:49 AM
Josh Jackson from Napa, California.  Lavin would be all over this number one, five star recruit.

Josh Jackson is the most talented kid I've ever seen. #1 pick in the draft, double digit nba all-star
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: bball purist on June 07, 2015, 01:51:21 AM
Josh Jackson from Napa, California.  Lavin would be all over this number one, five star recruit.
I "would be" all over him too....if I *were* St. John's HC....
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: JohnnyJungle on June 07, 2015, 02:05:02 AM
Well I'm a big Mustapha Heron fan. His strength for a guard is really unmatched. When he gets downhill in the paint it's very difficult to stop him and he can finish with contact. Additionally he's really good with the ball in his hands. He can pass, pull up, or drive. Really has a pro body already and is an instant difference maker. I don't see any recruit outside of Harry Giles, Josh Jackson, and Jayson Tatum having a greater impact year 1. Dennis Smith is in the convo too he's dynamite.

My other favorites are Terrance Ferguson then Frank Jackson but neither of these guys are on radar.

I'm still under the impression Rawle Alkins wants out of the area and not sold on his recent interest being very genuine. Even if he is I think he is a solid piece but I'm not oozing over him like I would with Heron. Also not convinced Heron following Slice is a given. He's played for a lot of teams/schools over the years and it's always about what have you done for me lately. Loyalty is not exactly a strength.
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: Marillac on June 07, 2015, 02:12:11 AM
Josh Jackson from Napa, California.  Lavin would be all over this number one, five star recruit.

Josh Jackson is the most talented kid I've ever seen. #1 pick in the draft, double digit nba all-star

If he was the most talented kid you've ever seen, you'd think he'd be able to win more high school games and wouldn't have been overwhelmed so much given the size and talent on the roster. 
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: Foad on June 07, 2015, 09:28:40 AM
Josh Jackson from Napa, California.  Lavin would be all over this number one, five star recruit.

Josh Jackson is the most talented kid I've ever seen. #1 pick in the draft, double digit nba all-star

If he was the most talented kid you've ever seen, you'd think he'd be able to win more high school games and wouldn't have been overwhelmed so much given the size and talent on the roster. 

I've never heard of Josh Johnson. Evidently as a freshman his team lost in the regional finals to the eventual state champion. That was the year his head coach DIED midseason. Now admittedly DYING is not as serious as having prostate cancer, for which Coach Lavin gets a complete and total pass, but sometimes death effects people such as when Cap Lavin died and how devastating that was for Steve Lavin and how difficult it was for him to be the first 50 year old orphan, it was a miracle he was able to continue at all. And then as a soph Josh on the state championship while averaging a near triple double - 28 points, 15 rebounds and 6 assists. As a junior he was named the national HS player of the year. So it doesn't sound like he was particularly overwhelmed and his teams seem to have won some games but I haven't seen any you tube clips of him so it's impossible to know for sure.
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: JohnnyJungle on June 07, 2015, 01:30:43 PM
Josh Jackson from Napa, California.  Lavin would be all over this number one, five star recruit.

Josh Jackson is the most talented kid I've ever seen. #1 pick in the draft, double digit nba all-star

If he was the most talented kid you've ever seen, you'd think he'd be able to win more high school games and wouldn't have been overwhelmed so much given the size and talent on the roster. 

There are guys who win a lot in youth sports who don't amount to too much after. Wins/Losses really have little impact on individual player's skill development. Additionally I'm not sure when or where he was overwhelmed.

I've seen Josh play 30+ times and he's unbelievable. Extremely poised, makes the right play, and makes everyone around him better.
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: Marillac on June 07, 2015, 11:09:16 PM
Josh Jackson from Napa, California.  Lavin would be all over this number one, five star recruit.

Josh Jackson is the most talented kid I've ever seen. #1 pick in the draft, double digit nba all-star

If he was the most talented kid you've ever seen, you'd think he'd be able to win more high school games and wouldn't have been overwhelmed so much given the size and talent on the roster. 

There are guys who win a lot in youth sports who don't amount to too much after. Wins/Losses really have little impact on individual player's skill development. Additionally I'm not sure when or where he was overwhelmed.

I've seen Josh play 30+ times and he's unbelievable. Extremely poised, makes the right play, and makes everyone around him better.

His team was 8-5 according to max preps (3 wins against one team) and they lost to Malik Ellison's Life Center team (not sure if Ellison played).

He's a good player and he'll be a lottery pick, but that is a huge claim and I just don't think he measures up anywhere next to guys like Anthony Davis, Wall, Rose, Durant, etc. he seems more like a slightly less talented Michael Beasley to me.
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: JohnnyJungle on June 07, 2015, 11:56:47 PM
Josh Jackson from Napa, California.  Lavin would be all over this number one, five star recruit.

Josh Jackson is the most talented kid I've ever seen. #1 pick in the draft, double digit nba all-star

If he was the most talented kid you've ever seen, you'd think he'd be able to win more high school games and wouldn't have been overwhelmed so much given the size and talent on the roster. 

There are guys who win a lot in youth sports who don't amount to too much after. Wins/Losses really have little impact on individual player's skill development. Additionally I'm not sure when or where he was overwhelmed.

I've seen Josh play 30+ times and he's unbelievable. Extremely poised, makes the right play, and makes everyone around him better.

His team was 8-5 according to max preps (3 wins against one team) and they lost to Malik Ellison's Life Center team (not sure if Ellison played).

He's a good player and he'll be a lottery pick, but that is a huge claim and I just don't think he measures up anywhere next to guys like Anthony Davis, Wall, Rose, Durant, etc. he seems more like a slightly less talented Michael Beasley to me.

Again I really don't value a team's record for evaluating their individual talent/potential. I'm really not sure where you get Michael Beasley from because they don't even play same position or have even remotely similar games.

Also FYI the team went 23-8 and lost 4 games in a row after Josh's father tragically died of a heart attack.
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: Marillac on June 08, 2015, 12:09:19 AM
Josh Jackson from Napa, California.  Lavin would be all over this number one, five star recruit.

Josh Jackson is the most talented kid I've ever seen. #1 pick in the draft, double digit nba all-star

If he was the most talented kid you've ever seen, you'd think he'd be able to win more high school games and wouldn't have been overwhelmed so much given the size and talent on the roster. 

I've never heard of Josh Johnson. Evidently as a freshman his team lost in the regional finals to the eventual state champion. That was the year his head coach DIED midseason. Now admittedly DYING is not as serious as having prostate cancer, for which Coach Lavin gets a complete and total pass, but sometimes death effects people such as when Cap Lavin died and how devastating that was for Steve Lavin and how difficult it was for him to be the first 50 year old orphan, it was a miracle he was able to continue at all. And then as a soph Josh on the state championship while averaging a near triple double - 28 points, 15 rebounds and 6 assists. As a junior he was named the national HS player of the year. So it doesn't sound like he was particularly overwhelmed and his teams seem to have won some games but I haven't seen any you tube clips of him so it's impossible to know for sure.


The kid is good...really good.  His physical talent alone warrants a lottery pick.  Dave's claim that he is the most talented kid he's EVER seen is far off IMO.  As for his prep record, I was surprised by the lack of success of his team, the newest basketball factory.  They have a half-dozen kids over 6'8 and the #1 player in the country and only went 8-5 according to Max Preps (I"m sure there were more games) and lost by 30 to West Oaks, a normal high school team that had a pair of 25 point losses itself.  You'd be hard pressed to find a kid ranked as high has him whose team didn't dominate.  No way Melo, Lebron, or Durant go 8-5 on that team and that is the kind of talent Dave was comparing him to. 

With that written, I think Prolific Prep will be much better next season, but he has a hole in his skill set that doesn't allow him to consistently dominate opponents like the other super talents we've seen.
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: JohnnyJungle on June 08, 2015, 01:28:10 AM
Josh Jackson from Napa, California.  Lavin would be all over this number one, five star recruit.

Josh Jackson is the most talented kid I've ever seen. #1 pick in the draft, double digit nba all-star

If he was the most talented kid you've ever seen, you'd think he'd be able to win more high school games and wouldn't have been overwhelmed so much given the size and talent on the roster. 

I've never heard of Josh Johnson. Evidently as a freshman his team lost in the regional finals to the eventual state champion. That was the year his head coach DIED midseason. Now admittedly DYING is not as serious as having prostate cancer, for which Coach Lavin gets a complete and total pass, but sometimes death effects people such as when Cap Lavin died and how devastating that was for Steve Lavin and how difficult it was for him to be the first 50 year old orphan, it was a miracle he was able to continue at all. And then as a soph Josh on the state championship while averaging a near triple double - 28 points, 15 rebounds and 6 assists. As a junior he was named the national HS player of the year. So it doesn't sound like he was particularly overwhelmed and his teams seem to have won some games but I haven't seen any you tube clips of him so it's impossible to know for sure.


The kid is good...really good.  His physical talent alone warrants a lottery pick.  Dave's claim that he is the most talented kid he's EVER seen is far off IMO.  As for his prep record, I was surprised by the lack of success of his team, the newest basketball factory.  They have a half-dozen kids over 6'8 and the #1 player in the country and only went 8-5 according to Max Preps (I"m sure there were more games) and lost by 30 to West Oaks, a normal high school team that had a pair of 25 point losses itself.  You'd be hard pressed to find a kid ranked as high has him whose team didn't dominate.  No way Melo, Lebron, or Durant go 8-5 on that team and that is the kind of talent Dave was comparing him to. 

With that written, I think Prolific Prep will be much better next season, but he has a hole in his skill set that doesn't allow him to consistently dominate opponents like the other super talents we've seen.

I guess I need to watch more youtube and read more max preps.
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: Foad on June 08, 2015, 07:31:56 AM
Dave's claim that he is the most talented kid he's EVER seen is far off IMO. 

I'd think you'd be used to hyperbole after four years of Marco Bourgault is the best shooter I've ever coached and Christian Jones has the best post moves I've ever seen in a freshman and Rysheed Jordan is the best passer since Jason Kidd.
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: MCNPA on June 08, 2015, 09:12:51 AM
He reminds me far more of Trevor Ariza after watching a little bit, but I have t seen him to the extent Dave has.  Doesn't remind me of Beasley who is more PF type.
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: Marillac on June 08, 2015, 01:13:37 PM
Josh Jackson from Napa, California.  Lavin would be all over this number one, five star recruit.

Josh Jackson is the most talented kid I've ever seen. #1 pick in the draft, double digit nba all-star

If he was the most talented kid you've ever seen, you'd think he'd be able to win more high school games and wouldn't have been overwhelmed so much given the size and talent on the roster. 

I've never heard of Josh Johnson. Evidently as a freshman his team lost in the regional finals to the eventual state champion. That was the year his head coach DIED midseason. Now admittedly DYING is not as serious as having prostate cancer, for which Coach Lavin gets a complete and total pass, but sometimes death effects people such as when Cap Lavin died and how devastating that was for Steve Lavin and how difficult it was for him to be the first 50 year old orphan, it was a miracle he was able to continue at all. And then as a soph Josh on the state championship while averaging a near triple double - 28 points, 15 rebounds and 6 assists. As a junior he was named the national HS player of the year. So it doesn't sound like he was particularly overwhelmed and his teams seem to have won some games but I haven't seen any you tube clips of him so it's impossible to know for sure.


The kid is good...really good.  His physical talent alone warrants a lottery pick.  Dave's claim that he is the most talented kid he's EVER seen is far off IMO.  As for his prep record, I was surprised by the lack of success of his team, the newest basketball factory.  They have a half-dozen kids over 6'8 and the #1 player in the country and only went 8-5 according to Max Preps (I"m sure there were more games) and lost by 30 to West Oaks, a normal high school team that had a pair of 25 point losses itself.  You'd be hard pressed to find a kid ranked as high has him whose team didn't dominate.  No way Melo, Lebron, or Durant go 8-5 on that team and that is the kind of talent Dave was comparing him to. 

With that written, I think Prolific Prep will be much better next season, but he has a hole in his skill set that doesn't allow him to consistently dominate opponents like the other super talents we've seen.

I guess I need to watch more youtube and read more max preps.

Any little bit will help your awful player analysis.  Russ Smith still not a Big East talent?  Working for under armour and being at events doesn't qualify you as any more of an expert than any poster on St. John's forums.  There are some equipment managers that see more basketball than any of us. 
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: JohnnyJungle on June 08, 2015, 02:07:51 PM
Josh Jackson from Napa, California.  Lavin would be all over this number one, five star recruit.

Josh Jackson is the most talented kid I've ever seen. #1 pick in the draft, double digit nba all-star

If he was the most talented kid you've ever seen, you'd think he'd be able to win more high school games and wouldn't have been overwhelmed so much given the size and talent on the roster. 

I've never heard of Josh Johnson. Evidently as a freshman his team lost in the regional finals to the eventual state champion. That was the year his head coach DIED midseason. Now admittedly DYING is not as serious as having prostate cancer, for which Coach Lavin gets a complete and total pass, but sometimes death effects people such as when Cap Lavin died and how devastating that was for Steve Lavin and how difficult it was for him to be the first 50 year old orphan, it was a miracle he was able to continue at all. And then as a soph Josh on the state championship while averaging a near triple double - 28 points, 15 rebounds and 6 assists. As a junior he was named the national HS player of the year. So it doesn't sound like he was particularly overwhelmed and his teams seem to have won some games but I haven't seen any you tube clips of him so it's impossible to know for sure.


The kid is good...really good.  His physical talent alone warrants a lottery pick.  Dave's claim that he is the most talented kid he's EVER seen is far off IMO.  As for his prep record, I was surprised by the lack of success of his team, the newest basketball factory.  They have a half-dozen kids over 6'8 and the #1 player in the country and only went 8-5 according to Max Preps (I"m sure there were more games) and lost by 30 to West Oaks, a normal high school team that had a pair of 25 point losses itself.  You'd be hard pressed to find a kid ranked as high has him whose team didn't dominate.  No way Melo, Lebron, or Durant go 8-5 on that team and that is the kind of talent Dave was comparing him to. 

With that written, I think Prolific Prep will be much better next season, but he has a hole in his skill set that doesn't allow him to consistently dominate opponents like the other super talents we've seen.

I guess I need to watch more youtube and read more max preps.

Any little bit will help your awful player analysis.  Russ Smith still not a Big East talent?  Working for under armour and being at events doesn't qualify you as any more of an expert than any poster on St. John's forums.  There are some equipment managers that see more basketball than any of us. 

If you don't think my analysis is good that's cool. It's simply just your opinion.

As for Russ Smith? I guess me and everyone else was skeptical of the 160lb guard competing in Big East. He was always a good scorer and thought he'd be better suited for lower level. I don't think I was off in saying that and I've always been proud of him and his Dad for believing he could do more. I don't recall you chiming in at the time saying he'd be a POY candidate. http://johnnyjungle.com/forum/index.php?topic=998.0

For my personal qualifications I've been blessed to be entrenched in the game of basketball as a profession for almost 10 years. I spend almost every weekend in a basketball gym in various parts of the country and watch/discuss with other like minded coaches and scouts. I think we have a lot of educated fans on JJ but it's impossible for you or anyone else to have as an informed opinion without having such access to the game/players. Doesn't mean your opinions are wrong but you simply don't have as much info to base it on.
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: bball purist on June 08, 2015, 02:51:24 PM
Josh Jackson from Napa, California.  Lavin would be all over this number one, five star recruit.

Josh Jackson is the most talented kid I've ever seen. #1 pick in the draft, double digit nba all-star

If he was the most talented kid you've ever seen, you'd think he'd be able to win more high school games and wouldn't have been overwhelmed so much given the size and talent on the roster. 

I've never heard of Josh Johnson. Evidently as a freshman his team lost in the regional finals to the eventual state champion. That was the year his head coach DIED midseason. Now admittedly DYING is not as serious as having prostate cancer, for which Coach Lavin gets a complete and total pass, but sometimes death effects people such as when Cap Lavin died and how devastating that was for Steve Lavin and how difficult it was for him to be the first 50 year old orphan, it was a miracle he was able to continue at all. And then as a soph Josh on the state championship while averaging a near triple double - 28 points, 15 rebounds and 6 assists. As a junior he was named the national HS player of the year. So it doesn't sound like he was particularly overwhelmed and his teams seem to have won some games but I haven't seen any you tube clips of him so it's impossible to know for sure.


The kid is good...really good.  His physical talent alone warrants a lottery pick.  Dave's claim that he is the most talented kid he's EVER seen is far off IMO.  As for his prep record, I was surprised by the lack of success of his team, the newest basketball factory.  They have a half-dozen kids over 6'8 and the #1 player in the country and only went 8-5 according to Max Preps (I"m sure there were more games) and lost by 30 to West Oaks, a normal high school team that had a pair of 25 point losses itself.  You'd be hard pressed to find a kid ranked as high has him whose team didn't dominate.  No way Melo, Lebron, or Durant go 8-5 on that team and that is the kind of talent Dave was comparing him to. 

With that written, I think Prolific Prep will be much better next season, but he has a hole in his skill set that doesn't allow him to consistently dominate opponents like the other super talents we've seen.

I guess I need to watch more youtube and read more max preps.

Any little bit will help your awful player analysis.  Russ Smith still not a Big East talent?  Working for under armour and being at events doesn't qualify you as any more of an expert than any poster on St. John's forums.  There are some equipment managers that see more basketball than any of us. 

If you don't think my analysis is good that's cool. It's simply just your opinion.

As for Russ Smith? I guess me and everyone else was skeptical of the 160lb guard competing in Big East. He was always a good scorer and thought he'd be better suited for lower level. I don't think I was off in saying that and I've always been proud of him and his Dad for believing he could do more. I don't recall you chiming in at the time saying he'd be a POY candidate. http://johnnyjungle.com/forum/index.php?topic=998.0 (http://johnnyjungle.com/forum/index.php?topic=998.0)

For my personal qualifications I've been blessed to be entrenched in the game of basketball as a profession for almost 10 years. I spend almost every weekend in a basketball gym in various parts of the country and watch/discuss with other like minded coaches and scouts. I think we have a lot of educated fans on JJ but it's impossible for you or anyone else to have as an informed opinion without having such access to the game/players. Doesn't mean your opinions are wrong but you simply don't have as much info to base it on.
I have to say that watching a player in person numerous times usually gives much more insight than any video can.  I wish I could see more HS games because the ones I watch are a lot of fun.
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: Marillac on June 08, 2015, 03:28:47 PM
Josh Jackson from Napa, California.  Lavin would be all over this number one, five star recruit.

Josh Jackson is the most talented kid I've ever seen. #1 pick in the draft, double digit nba all-star

If he was the most talented kid you've ever seen, you'd think he'd be able to win more high school games and wouldn't have been overwhelmed so much given the size and talent on the roster. 

I've never heard of Josh Johnson. Evidently as a freshman his team lost in the regional finals to the eventual state champion. That was the year his head coach DIED midseason. Now admittedly DYING is not as serious as having prostate cancer, for which Coach Lavin gets a complete and total pass, but sometimes death effects people such as when Cap Lavin died and how devastating that was for Steve Lavin and how difficult it was for him to be the first 50 year old orphan, it was a miracle he was able to continue at all. And then as a soph Josh on the state championship while averaging a near triple double - 28 points, 15 rebounds and 6 assists. As a junior he was named the national HS player of the year. So it doesn't sound like he was particularly overwhelmed and his teams seem to have won some games but I haven't seen any you tube clips of him so it's impossible to know for sure.


The kid is good...really good.  His physical talent alone warrants a lottery pick.  Dave's claim that he is the most talented kid he's EVER seen is far off IMO.  As for his prep record, I was surprised by the lack of success of his team, the newest basketball factory.  They have a half-dozen kids over 6'8 and the #1 player in the country and only went 8-5 according to Max Preps (I"m sure there were more games) and lost by 30 to West Oaks, a normal high school team that had a pair of 25 point losses itself.  You'd be hard pressed to find a kid ranked as high has him whose team didn't dominate.  No way Melo, Lebron, or Durant go 8-5 on that team and that is the kind of talent Dave was comparing him to. 

With that written, I think Prolific Prep will be much better next season, but he has a hole in his skill set that doesn't allow him to consistently dominate opponents like the other super talents we've seen.

I guess I need to watch more youtube and read more max preps.

Any little bit will help your awful player analysis.  Russ Smith still not a Big East talent?  Working for under armour and being at events doesn't qualify you as any more of an expert than any poster on St. John's forums.  There are some equipment managers that see more basketball than any of us. 

If you don't think my analysis is good that's cool. It's simply just your opinion.

As for Russ Smith? I guess me and everyone else was skeptical of the 160lb guard competing in Big East. He was always a good scorer and thought he'd be better suited for lower level. I don't think I was off in saying that and I've always been proud of him and his Dad for believing he could do more. I don't recall you chiming in at the time saying he'd be a POY candidate. http://johnnyjungle.com/forum/index.php?topic=998.0

For my personal qualifications I've been blessed to be entrenched in the game of basketball as a profession for almost 10 years. I spend almost every weekend in a basketball gym in various parts of the country and watch/discuss with other like minded coaches and scouts. I think we have a lot of educated fans on JJ but it's impossible for you or anyone else to have as an informed opinion without having such access to the game/players. Doesn't mean your opinions are wrong but you simply don't have as much info to base it on.

I was just messing around as usual, Dave.  It gets lost on the internet...it's probably been too long to do so since we drank at the gathering so you might have forgotten that I'm almost never serious.



Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: Marillac on June 08, 2015, 03:34:01 PM
Josh Jackson from Napa, California.  Lavin would be all over this number one, five star recruit.

Josh Jackson is the most talented kid I've ever seen. #1 pick in the draft, double digit nba all-star

If he was the most talented kid you've ever seen, you'd think he'd be able to win more high school games and wouldn't have been overwhelmed so much given the size and talent on the roster. 

I've never heard of Josh Johnson. Evidently as a freshman his team lost in the regional finals to the eventual state champion. That was the year his head coach DIED midseason. Now admittedly DYING is not as serious as having prostate cancer, for which Coach Lavin gets a complete and total pass, but sometimes death effects people such as when Cap Lavin died and how devastating that was for Steve Lavin and how difficult it was for him to be the first 50 year old orphan, it was a miracle he was able to continue at all. And then as a soph Josh on the state championship while averaging a near triple double - 28 points, 15 rebounds and 6 assists. As a junior he was named the national HS player of the year. So it doesn't sound like he was particularly overwhelmed and his teams seem to have won some games but I haven't seen any you tube clips of him so it's impossible to know for sure.


The kid is good...really good.  His physical talent alone warrants a lottery pick.  Dave's claim that he is the most talented kid he's EVER seen is far off IMO.  As for his prep record, I was surprised by the lack of success of his team, the newest basketball factory.  They have a half-dozen kids over 6'8 and the #1 player in the country and only went 8-5 according to Max Preps (I"m sure there were more games) and lost by 30 to West Oaks, a normal high school team that had a pair of 25 point losses itself.  You'd be hard pressed to find a kid ranked as high has him whose team didn't dominate.  No way Melo, Lebron, or Durant go 8-5 on that team and that is the kind of talent Dave was comparing him to. 

With that written, I think Prolific Prep will be much better next season, but he has a hole in his skill set that doesn't allow him to consistently dominate opponents like the other super talents we've seen.

I guess I need to watch more youtube and read more max preps.

Any little bit will help your awful player analysis.  Russ Smith still not a Big East talent?  Working for under armour and being at events doesn't qualify you as any more of an expert than any poster on St. John's forums.  There are some equipment managers that see more basketball than any of us. 

If you don't think my analysis is good that's cool. It's simply just your opinion.

As for Russ Smith? I guess me and everyone else was skeptical of the 160lb guard competing in Big East. He was always a good scorer and thought he'd be better suited for lower level. I don't think I was off in saying that and I've always been proud of him and his Dad for believing he could do more. I don't recall you chiming in at the time saying he'd be a POY candidate. http://johnnyjungle.com/forum/index.php?topic=998.0 (http://johnnyjungle.com/forum/index.php?topic=998.0)

For my personal qualifications I've been blessed to be entrenched in the game of basketball as a profession for almost 10 years. I spend almost every weekend in a basketball gym in various parts of the country and watch/discuss with other like minded coaches and scouts. I think we have a lot of educated fans on JJ but it's impossible for you or anyone else to have as an informed opinion without having such access to the game/players. Doesn't mean your opinions are wrong but you simply don't have as much info to base it on.
I have to say that watching a player in person numerous times usually gives much more insight than any video can.  I wish I could see more HS games because the ones I watch are a lot of fun.

I prefer video to be perfectly honest.  I have bad eye sight to begin with, but I hate not being able to rewind, pause, and slow-mo.  Full games are the best and I'm thankful that there is so much available the last few years.  I get to watch my old high school's football games a thousand miles away.  I used to love the ABCD camps when it was held at FDU, but I hated not being able to get a closer look.  I don't care if the ball goes in...rather see how a kid gets into his shot, gets the feet, and form, etc. 

Back to the point of the thread...Heron #1, but for those that haven't see Ponds play, I recommend watching some of his full games available online.  Big fan. 
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: JohnnyJungle on June 08, 2015, 05:40:50 PM
Josh Jackson from Napa, California.  Lavin would be all over this number one, five star recruit.

Josh Jackson is the most talented kid I've ever seen. #1 pick in the draft, double digit nba all-star

If he was the most talented kid you've ever seen, you'd think he'd be able to win more high school games and wouldn't have been overwhelmed so much given the size and talent on the roster. 

I've never heard of Josh Johnson. Evidently as a freshman his team lost in the regional finals to the eventual state champion. That was the year his head coach DIED midseason. Now admittedly DYING is not as serious as having prostate cancer, for which Coach Lavin gets a complete and total pass, but sometimes death effects people such as when Cap Lavin died and how devastating that was for Steve Lavin and how difficult it was for him to be the first 50 year old orphan, it was a miracle he was able to continue at all. And then as a soph Josh on the state championship while averaging a near triple double - 28 points, 15 rebounds and 6 assists. As a junior he was named the national HS player of the year. So it doesn't sound like he was particularly overwhelmed and his teams seem to have won some games but I haven't seen any you tube clips of him so it's impossible to know for sure.


The kid is good...really good.  His physical talent alone warrants a lottery pick.  Dave's claim that he is the most talented kid he's EVER seen is far off IMO.  As for his prep record, I was surprised by the lack of success of his team, the newest basketball factory.  They have a half-dozen kids over 6'8 and the #1 player in the country and only went 8-5 according to Max Preps (I"m sure there were more games) and lost by 30 to West Oaks, a normal high school team that had a pair of 25 point losses itself.  You'd be hard pressed to find a kid ranked as high has him whose team didn't dominate.  No way Melo, Lebron, or Durant go 8-5 on that team and that is the kind of talent Dave was comparing him to. 

With that written, I think Prolific Prep will be much better next season, but he has a hole in his skill set that doesn't allow him to consistently dominate opponents like the other super talents we've seen.

I guess I need to watch more youtube and read more max preps.

Any little bit will help your awful player analysis.  Russ Smith still not a Big East talent?  Working for under armour and being at events doesn't qualify you as any more of an expert than any poster on St. John's forums.  There are some equipment managers that see more basketball than any of us. 

If you don't think my analysis is good that's cool. It's simply just your opinion.

As for Russ Smith? I guess me and everyone else was skeptical of the 160lb guard competing in Big East. He was always a good scorer and thought he'd be better suited for lower level. I don't think I was off in saying that and I've always been proud of him and his Dad for believing he could do more. I don't recall you chiming in at the time saying he'd be a POY candidate. http://johnnyjungle.com/forum/index.php?topic=998.0

For my personal qualifications I've been blessed to be entrenched in the game of basketball as a profession for almost 10 years. I spend almost every weekend in a basketball gym in various parts of the country and watch/discuss with other like minded coaches and scouts. I think we have a lot of educated fans on JJ but it's impossible for you or anyone else to have as an informed opinion without having such access to the game/players. Doesn't mean your opinions are wrong but you simply don't have as much info to base it on.

I was just messing around as usual, Dave.  It gets lost on the internet...it's probably been too long to do so since we drank at the gathering so you might have forgotten that I'm almost never serious.





No doubt.
Title: Re: 2016 recruit you want the most?
Post by: bball purist on June 08, 2015, 09:53:56 PM
Josh Jackson from Napa, California.  Lavin would be all over this number one, five star recruit.

Josh Jackson is the most talented kid I've ever seen. #1 pick in the draft, double digit nba all-star

If he was the most talented kid you've ever seen, you'd think he'd be able to win more high school games and wouldn't have been overwhelmed so much given the size and talent on the roster. 

I've never heard of Josh Johnson. Evidently as a freshman his team lost in the regional finals to the eventual state champion. That was the year his head coach DIED midseason. Now admittedly DYING is not as serious as having prostate cancer, for which Coach Lavin gets a complete and total pass, but sometimes death effects people such as when Cap Lavin died and how devastating that was for Steve Lavin and how difficult it was for him to be the first 50 year old orphan, it was a miracle he was able to continue at all. And then as a soph Josh on the state championship while averaging a near triple double - 28 points, 15 rebounds and 6 assists. As a junior he was named the national HS player of the year. So it doesn't sound like he was particularly overwhelmed and his teams seem to have won some games but I haven't seen any you tube clips of him so it's impossible to know for sure.


The kid is good...really good.  His physical talent alone warrants a lottery pick.  Dave's claim that he is the most talented kid he's EVER seen is far off IMO.  As for his prep record, I was surprised by the lack of success of his team, the newest basketball factory.  They have a half-dozen kids over 6'8 and the #1 player in the country and only went 8-5 according to Max Preps (I"m sure there were more games) and lost by 30 to West Oaks, a normal high school team that had a pair of 25 point losses itself.  You'd be hard pressed to find a kid ranked as high has him whose team didn't dominate.  No way Melo, Lebron, or Durant go 8-5 on that team and that is the kind of talent Dave was comparing him to. 

With that written, I think Prolific Prep will be much better next season, but he has a hole in his skill set that doesn't allow him to consistently dominate opponents like the other super talents we've seen.

I guess I need to watch more youtube and read more max preps.

Any little bit will help your awful player analysis.  Russ Smith still not a Big East talent?  Working for under armour and being at events doesn't qualify you as any more of an expert than any poster on St. John's forums.  There are some equipment managers that see more basketball than any of us. 

If you don't think my analysis is good that's cool. It's simply just your opinion.

As for Russ Smith? I guess me and everyone else was skeptical of the 160lb guard competing in Big East. He was always a good scorer and thought he'd be better suited for lower level. I don't think I was off in saying that and I've always been proud of him and his Dad for believing he could do more. I don't recall you chiming in at the time saying he'd be a POY candidate. http://johnnyjungle.com/forum/index.php?topic=998.0 (http://johnnyjungle.com/forum/index.php?topic=998.0)

For my personal qualifications I've been blessed to be entrenched in the game of basketball as a profession for almost 10 years. I spend almost every weekend in a basketball gym in various parts of the country and watch/discuss with other like minded coaches and scouts. I think we have a lot of educated fans on JJ but it's impossible for you or anyone else to have as an informed opinion without having such access to the game/players. Doesn't mean your opinions are wrong but you simply don't have as much info to base it on.

I was just messing around as usual, Dave.  It gets lost on the internet...it's probably been too long to do so since we drank at the gathering so you might have forgotten that I'm almost never serious.
Forget your new nicknames with Moose, or Amarillac...I got dibs on Mariwhack....