i think theres no reason why we shouldnt have a local TOURNAMENT every year...forget about a single game with a few local schools...play it around christmas time, and have an 8 team tournament with the top 8 schools from the ny area in that year...then you can pick the best teams in ny in a given year from a pool of:
St Johns
Fordham
Syracuse
Hofstra
Columbia
Niagra
Iona
Manhattan
Buffalo
LIU
St Francis
am i forgetting someone?
It should just be NYC teams. You forgot Wagner.
STJ
Fordham
Columbia
St. Francis
LIU
Wagner
Manhattan
There are too many teams in the NY area: West Point, Canisius, Niagara, St. Bonaventure, Colgate, Cornell, Albany, Siena, and Marist are schools you forgot in NY.
Maybe to make it an even eight team playoff, they can invite the D-2 CUNY champ from the year before.