1985 was greater although I love the "birth and resurrection" analogy.
Few people remember BC's role in that NCAA tourney. But for a ball bouncing off a point guards knee with a minute left to go it would have been "Vatican Four". I forgot the guard, possibly Adams, erred with little to go and the lead over Memphis State, a team they outplayed throughout the game. But for that moment the 1985 Championship would never be considered anything less that the Big East "do you believe in miracles?".
Perhaps someone will match 3 teams but The ACC couldn't do it with 5 teams in the final 8. Ours is the the equivalent of the 56 game hitting streak of DiMaggio or Heiden's 6 or7 golds in Lake Placid in 1980