Close call Dave. Arch is a better college basketball player right now. Jordan has more upside. I have no doubt we would have more wins with Arch. But if Jordan continued to do what he has done recently, I think he will be first team all conference.
Jordan is more athletic and I think people equate that alone with talent. Shooting, decision-making, saavy, toughness all play into whether one is a talented basketball player. And I think Arch is better right now than Sheed in all of those areas (and Sheed is better than Arch in certain respects).