So you're comparing Lavin's and Mullin's first 12 months of recruiting to Anderson's first 4. Seems fair.
Are you intentionally being obtuse? You consistently seem to struggle with the basic recall of facts you are responding to.
Here is what I wrote:
“Lavin and Mullin brought in dynamic classes their first full year. I doubt Anderson comes close.”
The last sentence clearly states a future expectation. The book won’t be closed on that for another year.
Recruiting classes don’t just fall from the sky...there are rumors, quotes from players and coaches, final lists, momentum, etc.
By this time both Mullin and especially Lavin had tons of momentum and were sitting pretty for top ranked talent. Anderson is not even close to them.
I’ve already stated multiple times that I believe Anderson is a better coach than either Mullin or Lavin and that I have faith in him finishing off the roster—something they never could. I also said I think he will be a better judge of talent, but he needs to bring in the big fish or it’s sll for naught. That is a legitimate concern at this point.
I don’t hesitate to give the man credit, and I think my take on him has been very fair. I’m sorry if I don’t land on one extreme or the other like every other St. John’s fan.