Caraher is slow but he's smart and tough. He's not on the floor to blow by guys. He's there to set screens, pick & pop, make slip passes, and hit open shots. In crunch time I'd value a lot of these things. Especially since he has 0 fouls.
I might get Caraher by default
The offensive end isn't the problem for Caraher in this game. It's defense. He has 0 fouls because guys are blowing by him before he can move.
Rutherford, Williams, LJ, Champagnie, Sears for me