Lowry, Foye, and Ray is NBA caliber and if his eye didn't pop out of his head he probably would've been drafted. They also probably go to the final four if Ray was fully healthy.
My point being we don't have the players to overcome the problems that come with playing a "small" 4. Especially in the Big East.
I hardly call what Seton Hall does a success. They've won 5 in a row but that includes Rutgers, St. John's, Rutgers, Depaul. Not exactly murderer's row. They've got 4 out of 6 against top 10 teams. Let's see how Stix does during that run.