I voted for McCaffrey. I like Greenberg and I think we'd make a solid run in his tenure, but I doubt we'd ever be top 5 in the conference regularly.
I think Donoghue is the most intriguing of all the coaches on this list--and might have the highest ceiling. He is far and above Greenberg and just about everyone on this list in terms of x's and o's. The question with him is can he get non-Ivy league kids to play that smart/well?
McAffrey is great IMO. He has won everywhere he's been. He's coached in the Big East. He employs a system that recruits would love and that would fit our current roster. He dominated his conference for three years and has won NCAA tournament games despite worse 3-pt shooting than we had this year and a PG that simply cannot score. Sound familiar?
Is Greenberg really that great of a recruiter? I honestly don't know the answer to that.
I'm still holding out hope for an A+ like Donovan as opposed to an A or A- like McAffrey or a B+ like Greenberg.