I thought they could win. Didn't think they WOULD win, really (but I like positive predictions). People are being a little bipolar about this team. They have an effin' tough January, and if watching your team lose 2,3,4 straight makes you wilt, you're gonna wilt. I'd like it if the Johnnies showed better against either of the last 2 teams - that's disconcerting.
But this team has to pick its battles; there's not really enough firepower to knock off all the top teams. And that's okay; if the Johnnies get to the tourney, it's as an 8 seed or lower, which is to say they're not a top-25 team. And that makes sense - they're better than previous years, but the rest of the league used St. John's as toilet paper for years. Those elite teams, generally, aren't much worse.
St. John's could use the Notre Dame game as a win. They should be elated (and on their way) with a win over G'Town or Louisville on the road. And they BADLY need to beat Cincy. If they don't, I don't know that the team can recover and go to the tournament.
But you have to remember that when we're down on the team or when we're up on the team, they're playing out the most realistic scenario here. Can't call them a damned bubble team after losing (badly) to the #4 team in the country.