1. Start by reading the book "Lapchick: The Life of a Legendary Player and Coach in the Glory Days of Basketball" by Gus Alfieri
2. Focus your paper "not" on the history of SJ BB (just give a two page summary) but on how the success of the program was mostly inseparably tied to basically four great coaches - Buck Freeman, Joe Lapchick, Frank McGuire and Lou Carnesecca.
3. Show how these coaches were the only SJ coaches to consistently win over 71% of their games and correlate that to the number of NIT and NCAA invitations.
4. Show that "after coach C" that in 20 years not one coach has won more than 62% until Steve Lavin was hired.
5. Do try to interview coach C, even if just for a few minutes for reference purposes. Ask him just one simple question like what makes coaching today's players different from the players of his era and quote him. Then leave it at that.
6. Use a "premise" to show how coaches' "name market value" was important in SJ success while hiring poor market names like Mahoney, Franschilla, and Norm Roberts were disastrous. Comapre winning records and post-season invitations.
Finally, do not take any negative advice from folks who would "poison" your paper with hater references. SJ did not have just one great year but many. They won 6 NITs when the NIT meant something and have been to 28 NCAA tournaments and are in the top 8 in all-time college bb wins. Four great Hall of Fame coaches made SJ synonymous with college basketball. It took four lesser names (Mahoney, Fraschilla, Jarvis and Roberts) to destroy that reputation in a 20 year period.
Best of luck!