Saw that Vitale also put a top 40 out. Think he had St. Johns at #37.
Interestingly enough, Vitale has 5 Big East Schools in his top 40 including SJU. He only has 4 ACC schools and 3 AAC schools I believe.
That's nice but let's be honest when you start ranking teams towards the end of the top 40 it becomes very subjective. In other words I could do a top 60 and have more teams from conference X then Y. So what?
Kind of like the NCAA Committee giving out the last few at large bids. Is there much difference between the last 2-3 teams picked as opposed to the last 2-3 teams that just missed?
More importantly look at everyone's pre-season top 10-15 (which is a little less subjective) totally DOMINATED by teams from the Big 10 and ACC (including teams like Louisville who is a soon to be ACC).
No current new Big East teams. That has to change. In other words in the next few years the Georgetown's, Marquette's, Villanova's and hopefully SJU's are going to have to emerge on the level of the top BIG 10 and ACC schools in terms of recruiting and play for the new Big East to be considered an elite conference.
Remember what made the Big East great since the expansion to 16 was not just the depth (because they had some bad teams as well) but the great teams/elite teams that consistently emerged from the conference every year. From 2006 to 2013 the Big East had a no. 1 seed in the NCAA's every year except for 2007 and 2008 and Georgetown was a 2 seed both those years.
And in years like 2006 (UCONN, Villanova), 2009 (Louisville, UCONN and Pitt) you had MULTIPLE no. 1 seeds.
Right now the current makeup of the new Big East I cannot see anyone next year at this point being on that level. Perhaps someone emerges next year. Could happen. Not the end of the world if it doesn't. I certainly think SJU can real good next year.
But more importantly it has to emerge in the next few years on a consistent basis for it to be a top echelon conference.