Dont go back as far some y'all, but one from my time stand out amongst others:
1989 St. Anthony's
Bobby Hurley
Terry Dehere
Jerry Walker
Roderick Rhodes
Jose Ortiz
Danny Hurley
32-0, state champs, USA Today champs.
115-5 in four years wit Hurley, Walker and Dehere
This has to be the choice. Walker and Ortiz were men, Hurley and Dehere were a sensational backcourt, and Rhodes was a stud from day one. Three first round picks on that team 1-3 and Walker was a manchild capable of holding his own against any high school big man. Oh, and the coach wasn't too shabby either.
Terry Dehere was my favorite college player of all-time, and ended his career as the leading scorer in Big East history.