| Position | 2008-2009 | 2009-2010 | 2010-2011 | 2011-2012 | 2012-2013 |
| PG | Malik Boothe | Malik Boothe | Malik Boothe | |
| PG | | Malik Stith | Malik Stith | Malik Stith | Malik Stith |
| PG | Tyshwan Edmondson |
| SG | Paris Horne | Paris Horne | Paris Horne | |
| SG | Quincy Roberts | Quincy Roberts | Quincy Roberts | Quincy Roberts |
| SG | | Omari Lawrence | Omari Lawrence | Omari Lawrence | Omari Lawrence |
| SG | | Dwight Hardy | Dwight Hardy | | |
| SF | Anthony Mason | Anthony Mason |
| SF | DJ Kennedy | DJ Kennedy | DJ Kennedy | |
| PF | Justin Burrell | Justin Burrell | Justin Burrell | |
| PF | Rob Thomas | Rob Thomas | Rob Thomas | |
| PF | Sean Evans | Sean Evans | Sean Evans | |
| PF | | Justin Brownlee | Justin Brownlee | |
| C | Tomas Jasiulionis |
| C | Dele Coker | Dele Coker | Dele Coker | |
| C | Phil Wait | | | |
|
| Available* | | 0 | 1 | 9 | 1 |
* Amount of scholarships available if full allotment is used in prior years.
** Omari Lawrence, Dwight Hardy, Malik Stith, and Justin Brownlee have signed LOIs to play for St. John's.
*** Anthony Mason is applying for a medical redshirt to gain eligibility for the 2009-2010 year.
****Tyshwan Edmondson and Phil Wait have announced their intentions to transfer.