The similarities to the Norm Roberts offense are alarming, but I think this group has more offensive talent than we’ve seen under Coach Anderson. The new guys aren’t liabilities like they were last year. With the exception of Keita, who is a big time project, all of the new guys can play.
As bad as the half court offense is - and it's bad - the I think the half court defense is the problem. Break the press and get awarded a lay-up or an open three doesn't to me seem like a workable defensive scheme. A lot will depend on Soriano's commitment on that end.
The broader question: How many of these guys would you rather have Anderson than
Thad Matta
Dan Hurley
Greg McDermott
Tony Stubblefield
Patrick Ewing
Shaka Smart
Ed Cooley
Shaheen Holloway
Kyle Neptune
Sean Miller
I can see Stubblefield and Ewing - although both are arguably better recruiters than IMA. Hurley maybe, I'm not sold on him, although again he's a better recruiter. And I'll throw in Kyle Neptune, because I've never heard of him, but whoever he is he's got the stink of Jay Wright on him and that'll sustain him for a while. That means Anderson's at best the seventh best coach in the league and probably among the three worst. If I didn't root for SJU to lose every game they play I'd be less than sanguine.