If you are going to sarcastically call somebody a genius, please at least spell "know" correctly. Also, it is "argument," ok?
Secondly, there are only seven ranked Big East teams and, G'town is #25 and, IMO, undeserving of a rank at 12-6, 3-4.
I actually agree with you that a conference should be measured by all of its members and not just the top and bottom teams. That is why I believe the ACC is better. Miami, Va Tech, FSU, and BC could all be ranked at this point. In fact, Va Tech and Miami definately should be ranked.
In the pomeroy rankings, the ACC is #1 and the Big East is #3. Also in the RPI, the ACC is #1 and the Big East is #3.
Still so silly? I must know something about basketball, because I paid my way through Columbia in cash off of sports betting.