I use rscihoops.com for historical rankings. That guy amasses the top 6-10 rankings and then averages them out thereby creating the closest to a consensus ranking you can find. Problem is it only goes back to the HS class of '98 so Artest isn't included. Can't really find archives on any of the major sites going back earlier.
FWIW in that class of 1998 for STJ AG was ranked 23, Erick 28, Ernest Brown 66. In 99 no STJ's in top 100, in 00 Cook was 12, Darius was 3, Diakite 52, in 01 nobody, in 02 Ingram was 28, 03-06 nobody, in 07 JB was 79, no one in 08.