He was a highly-touted recruit who failed to qualify, and then didn't take the steps that others did to ensure that he ended up at SJU (or express the same desire that Amir or, to a lesser extent, even Jakar did before re-committing). And you are surprised with the negative commentary when he goes elsewhere? Even though St. John's cut ties, we all wanted him here and were disappointed that it didn't happen...
As far as the comments about his eligibility, I think people would have expressed those concerns wherever he committed.
None of that changes that he was well worth the gamble for your squad, Baldi. If I were you, my only concern is that the team chemistry will be thrown off by too many players trying to get theirs, since there are so many new faces and transfers.