think theres much of a difference between a 4 star player and a 5 star player ?

  • 6 replies
  • 952 views
I'm looking at the top 100 players for 2011. Kentucky has a bunch of 5 star players and St. John's has about 5   4 star players ranked in the top 100.  You wonder with good coaching a 4 star player could be a better player then the 5 star guys. Lavin assembled a good coaching staff to develop the players.
What kind of staff does Kentucky have ?

Poison

  • *****
  • 16896
Dwayne Wade and Tim Duncan were 4 star players. Felipe Lopez and Luther Wright were both ranked number one in their class.
« Last Edit: October 31, 2010, 08:39:34 PM by Poison »

If High School kids were still draft elgible...a 5 star might be a lottery pick where a 4 star might be a post lottery pick?

We get so caught up in the number of stars next to someones name. Stars don't measure heart and competive spirt. Lopez was considered #1 in his class and we can all thing of college players that had better college career then him. These rating are a crap shot. AAU competion does help because you can see the players compete against the same level of competion.

Poison

  • *****
  • 16896
There are never any guarantees. Lopez wasn't half the player that Marcus Hatten was, and Hatten came out of nowhere.

TONYD3

  • *****
  • 5578
Dwayne Wade and Tim Duncan were 4 star players. Felipe Lopez and Luther Wright were both ranked number one in their class.
Lebron and John Wall were also 5 stars and the top rated players in there class. In football I think 5 star players are much more important because even if the player is great he stays atleast 3 years. In basketball alot of the elite 5 star players leave after 1 or 2 years.
 

The difference between 1-25 and 50-75 and 100-150 is pretty vast in some cases. I left out 25-50 and 75-100 because I feel those areas get a little more grey. You're always going to find exceptions but usually the creme rises to the top.

If you want a better judge go to Rivals Top 150 and look over past 5 years. Pick two random numbers and compare those over the 5 year span. 20/40 50/60
Follow Johnny Jungle on Twitter at @Johnny_Jungle