I disagree with you there Baldi. If we beat Xavier, Gtown and Marquette we are definitely in because of the # of top 50 wins, combined with the SOL, a few top 25 RPI wins, and even more wins when you consider the top 100.
The SOL is very good even with the D-2 win.
If we had a good RPI but no wins in the top 50 and only a few (or none) in the top 100 we'd be in trouble. But we didn't have the above last year when I think we were probably a Big East tourney win over Providence from getting in (though some speculate we needed 2).
2-2 may need a win in the BE tournament to get over the hump