Do you trust Lavin in the long term? SJU invested in Lavin and he brought in better players (a herald top three...sort of) and the result was one post season win...In the NIT. Lavin may bring in an even better class and most likely they will leave even sooner then the players from his first five years. Do people on this board have faith that he learned his lesson and won't stop recruiting or at least change his strategy and stop swinging for the fences for every recruit and go for players that have character and are more of a guaranteed to stay three or four years and will not have as many off the court issue.
Even if Lavin is offered a three extension he still has an out after two years because he will need an extension soon after to continue to recruit, or he just leaves and we have to bring in a new coach that is stuck with a roster full of players that are not his.
If a new coach comes in he can recruit his own players right away and rebuild the program in his image. Is it better to suffer in the short term to build a better program in the long term.
I'm not saying fire Lavin, I will say I don't trust him at all. Something has to change in that atheltic department regardless of what happens to Lavin. Either new AD, new coach, change out assistance, new infrastructure, all the above, or some changes.
There is a new President that is already changing SJU (for the better) and some kind of change in the BBall program is a must to advance to the next level of actually winning games, rather then just being invited to them.