Think we ought to wait until at least a few games?
I'm not anointing anyone here. I've never seen any of these freshmen play before. Just wanted to get a sense if he compared to anyone St. John's has had before. Slender, 6' 7" forward reminded me of someone. Shit, we spent 8 months and 3,000 posts comparing Kyle Anderson to everyone from Jalen Rose to Magic Johnson.
Harkless is probably the most polished freshmen we have in our 2011 class. Yes, we're certainly gonna be shorthanded and small. But, the freshmen who are gonna suit up are probably the most polished ones of the bunch.
Agreed IMO even before they were ruled inelgible I thought that Jakarr, Norvel & Amir were the most raw out of the group and would take a longer time to reach their potential. Obviously it would be better if they were here this year but it might help their development in the long run if they have another year to work on their weaknesses before they suit up as freshman
Yeah, but what hurts about those 3 is that WHILE they were working on their weaknesses and and taking a "longer time to reach their potential", it was likely they'd have STILL been better 80% of the players in D1 at their positions. Looking back at RSCI rankings, St Johns hasn't had a TOTAL of 3 top 50 recruits in the last Decade combined (till THIS year with the 4 that ARE here)..
Re "better than 80%" - the TRULY simplistic math goes - 15 players on a roster, so appx 5000 D-1 players. 5 postions on the court, so 1000 players per position. So appx 250 players from each of 4 recruiting classes at each position. Better than 80% of them? That would mean top 50 recruit or better. All three ARE top 50 recruits.
All thre are imporrtant. I really want to see Amir succeed. But Pelle? Even as a raw, developing player, he is SO superior a talent that every game he's NOT on the court "developing" is a crying shame, because he would have been more talented than almost EVERY player he would have gone against. With the Big East and NCAA (or NIT) tourneys, there are a potential FORTY TWO games to be played this season. He would have out-talented his opponent in most of those, and in 2013, had 42 games experience torwards out-skilling them nxt year. Only brightside I can see is that he could conceivably still be manning the center spot for us in 2016 now.