I'm close with all the Hurley's and I like Bobby a lot but he hasn't proven a thing yet.
To say Bobby Hurley hasn't proven enough is debatable, but to say that Hurley hasn't "proven a thing" is just foolish and flat out false.
Two years ago, I would have agreed with you. Hell, after last season I might have agreed with you, but he made the dance and his team played a five seed down to the last seconds. They showed more fight than we did against an eight seed. His Buffalo team was beating undefeated soon-to-be national champion, Kentucky, by five at the half in Lexington and they were up on Wisconsin in Madison at the half as well.
Bobby took over for a fired coach that won only 14 games prior. He signed a guy in a matter of days that won the MAC Player of the year this year. He signed a dynamic point guard in his first month that just averaged 15.4 and 4.6 and dropped 15 on West Virginia. He followed that up by signing a fantastic freshman PG this past season that can play in the Big East and went for 8 and 6 against WV.
This year he signed a top Juco prospect from Midland and a former top 75 recruit--to SUNY BUFFALO--a team that never danced before Hurley took over. His credibility among high school guards is out of this world. He would have landed IB if he were here...no doubt in my mind.
Is there a risk with taking a guy that essentially was only a co-head coach for three years and a head coach in the MAC for just two years? Sure. But, unlike Norm Roberts, everything in this guy's past suggests he will excel here.
How many winning seasons in the MAC would Bobby have to have for you think he has accomplished something? Because Buffalo is going to win 30 games next season, and then it will be too late.
He's proven he can identify and develop talent. He's proven he can recruit transfers. He's proven he can recruit JUCOs. He's proven he's a strong x's and o's coach. He's proven he can game plan. He's proven he can motivate his team. He's proven he can rebuild a program.