wagner did beat us back in the day when pj carlesimo coached them.
it's sad that our program has progressed so little that we're still worried about them and bucknell.
Per this from Rumble, they never beat us under PJ:
The two schools have played each other sporadically since 1935 and the Red Storm owns a 15-2 series advantage. Wagner last won against St. John’s in 1956.
They beat Alabama in the Lapchick Tournament under PJ, which was their last win over a ranked opponent until Pitt last year. I think they also took us to overtime under PJ, but we won the game. Think I read something about that once.
Also, to whomever was making out that list, Colombia is a third local team that has not beaten us the last 2 decades. Other then that, none I can think of (if you don't consider NJIT or FDU to be local).